Sean | March 30, 2025

What Questions Should I Ask My Car Accident Attorney?

After being injured in an auto collision, you need an experienced car accident attorney to recover fair compensation for both your financial and intangible losses. To find the right lawyer, schedule free consultations with potential law firms to see which one best represents your case needs. It’s essential that you ask the right questions to ensure you feel acknowledged, understood, and confident in their ability to advocate for your right to recover compensation. If you’ve suffered an injury, schedule a free consultation with an experienced St. Petersburg car accident attorney to explore your legal options.

Start your free consultation

Preparing for Your Free Consultation

Free consultations offer insight into how a prospective car accident attorney presents themselves and interacts with clients. Do they inspire confidence when explaining their services and answering your questions, or do they appear pushy? You want an authentic attorney who sees you and cares. Are their responses direct, or do they avoid giving clear answers? Pay attention to these tells before hiring a lawyer. Free consultations typically last between 30 and 60 minutes. To ensure you get the most out of your initial meeting, be prepared with the following information and evidence:

• Police Reports: Bring the accident report or police report number. It includes essential accident details, such as the date, location, and description. Police reports can be vital evidence in proving liability (fault) in a car accident. They may also contain contact information for key witnesses to the collision.
• Insurance Details: Come prepared with your auto insurance policy information, including your insurer’s contact details and coverage limits. You should always discuss any communication you’ve entertained with the at-fault driver’s insurance company, including admitting partial liability, stating you were uninjured, or providing a recorded statement.
• Witness Information: If you gathered contact information or statements from witnesses to your car accident, bring them. Lawyers will contact witnesses to verify statements, obtain any new relevant information, and secure valuable testimonies when claims go to court.
• Visual Evidence: Visual evidence from a car accident can be compelling and must be gathered quickly before being lost or destroyed. To document the severity of injuries, bring pictures of injuries immediately following a collision. Video evidence from dashcams or cellular phones should be brought when applicable. Once hired, attorneys work fast to recover traffic camera and security footage from surrounding businesses when available.
• Medical Records: Injured parties should come prepared with medical records or documentation, such as imaging and prescription medications, if they are in possession. If not, car accident attorneys will obtain written consent when you hire them and submit a formal request to your healthcare provider. Detailed medical records are vital for successfully recovering compensation.

If you’ve been keeping a post-accident journal documenting your pain and suffering, bring that to your free consultation as well. The goal is to arrive organized and with as much information as possible so that a car accident attorney can fully understand your case. Knowing the specifics helps inform potential case strategies and outcomes. You should consult a lawyer right away after experiencing injuries from a car accident, even if you may not have some or all of the evidence mentioned. That’s okay. An experienced car accident attorney will know how to gather the necessary evidence once they accept your case.

Questions About Experience

You want to ask your car accident attorney questions about their experience. You wouldn’t knowingly take your car to a mechanic on their first day working on your vehicle. Similarly, you shouldn’t entrust your legal needs to a lawyer unprepared to handle the complexities of car accident claims. You should hire a lawyer with experience representing clients in similar case circumstances. Questions you might ask a car accident attorney about their experience include the following:

• How long have you been practicing personal injury law?
• Are car accidents your primary practice area?
• Do you have experience handling car accident cases like mine?
• What is your success rate in negotiating claims like mine?

The vast majority of car accident claims are settled outside of court. However, roughly one in twenty injury claims require litigation. Ask prospective car accident lawyers about their trial experience. If your claim is the one in twenty, you need an attorney with courtroom experience to represent your case. Ask questions like: Do you have trial experience with car accident cases like mine? What is your success rate with litigating cases like mine?

Questions About Case Assessment

In your initial meeting, lawyers assess the potential strength and value of your car accident claim by examining the details of your collisions, injuries, and other factors before deciding on the best legal action to pursue compensation. Questions to ask a car accident attorney regarding their case assessment include the following:

• Do you believe my case is strong enough to pursue legal action? 
• What is your opinion on the likelihood of successfully securing compensation? 

When assessing your case, car accident lawyers will need to understand your collision’s how, when, and where. Be sure to inform them about the other parties involved in the accident and whether there are any witnesses. You should also clarify any prior health issues that can affect your current injuries. After learning the circumstances of your collision, a car accident attorney should be able to answer assessment questions clearly.

Questions About Case Strategy

Experienced lawyers can offer valuable insights into the specifics of your claim and its potential development. Although every car accident is unique, many share similar circumstances. A car accident lawyer’s experience aids in identifying these similarities and formulating case strategies and potential outcomes. Important questions to ask a car accident attorney regarding case strategy include:

• What are the strengths and weaknesses of my car accident claim? 
• What is your legal strategy for recovering compensation for my claim?
• What are the factors that influence the potential outcomes of my case?

After discussing case strategy with prospective lawyers, you should feel confident and convinced of their ability to secure a fair settlement for your injuries and damages. If they are vague or unable to instill that faith, you should consult another car accident attorney.

Questions About Settlement Potential

You should inquire about your potential settlement value after a collision. Lawyers can’t give you exact figures, but they may provide an estimated range once they understand the specifics of your situation. Many factors can influence settlement amounts, including the severity of your injuries, lost income, effects on your daily life, and anticipated long-term care needs. Questions to ask a car accident attorney regarding potential settlements include:

• What damages can I pursue in my car accident claim?
• How will you calculate the value of my car accident claim?
• What are the likely settlement options for my case?
• Will compensation cover past, current, and future injury-related medical costs?
• What are the potential tax implications of my car accident settlement?

Car accident attorneys assess the economic and non-economic damages in your claim. Economic losses from a car accident typically encompass medical expenses, long-term medical care, vehicle repairs, and lost income. Non-economic or intangible losses cover compensation for pain and suffering, decreased quality of life, disability and disfigurement, and loss of consortium (companionship, love, spousal relations).

Questions About Case Timeline

You’ll want to ask a car accident attorney how long they anticipate it taking before securing a settlement. It’s impossible to provide an exact date and time. The length of a settlement depends on the severity of your injuries, the length and costs of healthcare treatments, and the impact of your injuries on daily life. However, after learning the circumstances of your car accident, they may provide valuable insight into how long your case may take. Ask questions like: What is a typical timeline for a car accident claim like mine?

Questions About Payment Fee Structure

Car accident attorneys typically work under contingency fee arrangements to ensure their clients face no upfront or out-of-pocket costs. They recognize the financial challenges that motor vehicle accidents can create and strive to prevent any additional burden. These fee arrangements also give clients peace of mind; attorneys are only compensated if they win their cases. If they don’t win, you don’t owe them anything.

However, you may encounter a car accident attorney operating under a fixed fee or hourly rate. It’s necessary to have potential lawyers clarify their fee structure. Questions you should ask a car accident to understand their fee structure include:

• Do you charge a contingency fee or an hourly rate?
• How much is your contingency fee? 
• Are there additional fees if my case requires litigation?

Contingency fee arrangements motivate car accident attorneys to vigorously pursue compensation for damages in your case. If an attorney does not win, claimants may still be responsible for legal expenses, such as court filing fees. Request a breakdown of all potential fees to avoid financial surprises later. There’s no compelling reason to hire a car accident attorney who does not offer contingency fee arrangements. 

Questions About Communication 

Communication is necessary for building trust and confidence with clients. You’ll want to understand your car accident attorney’s communication style, their preferred methods of communication, and how frequently they communicate with you about your claim. Questions you should ask your car accident attorney about communication include:

• How often will you update me about my car accident claim?
• Will you communicate via email or by phone?
• Will you accept my phone calls or respond to my emails?

Injured individuals will want to know who is working on their car accident case. During your consultation, have lawyers clarify who will work on your case. If you go into the attorney-client relationship believing you’ll have access to communications with them but only ever speak to a paralegal, that can become an issue. Ask questions like: Who will be my primary contact person at your firm? Will you answer my calls directly?

Questions About Personal Role

Understanding your personal role in the car accident claims or lawsuit processes is important before hiring an attorney. Ask questions like: How can I help ensure a smooth claims process? What evidence am I responsible for providing? Typically, your primary role is to provide accurate information about the collision and related medical treatment to your lawyer.

Car accident cases involve police reports, medical records and bills, witness contact information, and receipts for expenses relating to your injuries. You must also keep your pain and suffering documented in a journal. Entries should detail physical pain levels, sleep disturbances, emotional distress (anger, fear, sadness), functional limitations, and other injury symptoms.

Why You Need a Car Accident Attorney

If you’ve suffered an injury in a collision that wasn’t your fault, you need a car accident attorney to review your case and protect your legal right to compensation. They can provide an honest assessment, identify strengths and weaknesses, develop potential strategies, and prepare for possible outcomes. The benefits of hiring a car accident lawyer to handle your claim include the following:

• Through case and accident scene investigation
• Collection and preservation of evidence
• Witness statements and testimonies
• Comprehensive claim valuation of damages
• Skilled negotiations with liable insurance companies

When insurance companies and lawyers fail to settle claims, a car accident attorney can file a civil lawsuit to fight for your right to compensation. They will enter discovery, prepare witnesses, and continue negotiating behind the scenes, hoping to settle before pre-trial motions. Most cases result in pre-trial settlements. However, if your case proceeds to court, they will represent it before a judge and jury.

Consult an Experienced Car Accident Attorney Today

Schedule your free consultation with an experienced car accident lawyer today to get started on your claim. You’ll want to determine a plan for securing a fair settlement for your injuries and damages.

Start your free consultation